The Vault Is Open

How a Federal Judge Handed Musk’s Man the Keys to America’s Financial Data

Apr 12, 2025

Remember Judge Jeannette A. Vargas?

Biden appointee. Harvard-Yale pedigree. Longtime SDNY prosecutor. Celebrated as the quiet, competent kind of Democrat who restores “norms.” The kind who’s supposed to protect the system from creeping authoritarianism.

She just ruled that a 26-year-old former defense tech engineer, now working for Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), can be granted access to federal financial systems containing the private data of millions of Americans. And she did it not because the risk disappeared, but because the procedures were followed.

This is how institutional failure operates: not loudly, but procedurally. Not with scandal, but with a login.

From Scandal to Access in Under Two Months

When DOGE first embedded itself in the Treasury Department, it did so through a figure named Marko Elez, who was later found to have mishandled sensitive information and posted offensive content online. After his exit, the Treasury and Musk’s DOGE operation installed Ryan Wunderly in his place.

Wunderly, 26, previously worked as an engineer at Anduril, a defense firm with deep ties to tech venture capital and Peter Thiel’s investment network. He has no known experience in government finance or federal systems, but he did pass cybersecurity training and receive security clearance.

And based on that, Judge Vargas approved his access to sensitive Treasury payment systems, including those that manage Social Security payouts, vendor contracts, and individual payee data. This wasn’t a full repeal of her earlier injunction blocking DOGE access, but it was a pivot and a soft opening of the door. The first legal foothold for Musk’s government reengineering project inside a mission-critical federal agency.

What Just Got Authorized

Let’s be clear: this access isn’t theoretical. According to court documents, Wunderly is now authorized, under limited conditions, to work directly with Treasury’s payment infrastructure, which includes:

Social Security numbers
Banking and routing data
Federal payment flows
Confidential payee information

This is the digital backbone of the U.S. government’s financial operations, and it’s now accessible to someone whose authority comes from an executive order, not from congressional confirmation or public accountability. In a moment of deepening political repression, what safeguards are in place to prevent abuse? What prevents this data from being leveraged, not for efficiency, but for political ends? If you’re still putting faith in ‘the law’ to restrain this administration, take a look at the sheer number of injunctions it’s already absorbed or ignored. That’s not oversight it’s just another performance in the ‘Law and Order’ Kabuki Theater that is this administrations entire approach to established law.

Judge Vargas didn’t say this was ideal. She said it was allowable. Because the vetting process, post-scandal, had been “sufficient.” The precedent? If a private-sector technocrat passes internal training, they can be embedded in federal systems previously off-limits to political appointees.

The Bigger Picture: What’s Not Being Said

This isn’t about Wunderly personally. There’s no accusation of malice or misconduct.
But that’s exactly the point. The danger isn’t the man. It’s the model.

This is about what DOGE represents: an ideology that sees government not as a civic responsibility, but as a broken machine that must be debugged by billionaires, for billionaires.

Musk’s murky and hard to pin down agenda is being enacted through executive staffing, data access, and institutional disruption. It’s less a coup and more a refactoring, rewriting the code of government behind the scenes. And the fact that it’s happening with the tacit approval of a Democratic-appointed judge is not just ironic. It’s sobering.

Because it proves this isn’t about partisanship. It’s about institutional softness, about systems that will yield to power if it’s patient, credentialed, and says all the right legal things.

Procedure Isn’t Protection

Judge Vargas didn’t break the law. She didn’t abuse her discretion.
What she did was worse: she followed every rule while allowing a dangerous precedent to take root. She gave conditional approval, not carte blanche.
But in a world where Musk’s DOGE is testing every door, a crack is all he needs.

We expect Trump to overreach.
We expect Musk to push boundaries.
But when the courts nod along, that’s when the firewall fails.

Cogent’s Substack

Discussion about this post